DSTs and the Springing LLC: Navigating the Complex World of Tax-Advantaged Real Estate Investments

Navigating the world of real estate investment can be a complex journey with numerous strategies and vehicles to choose from. One such investment option is the Delaware Statutory Trust (DST), a vehicle that offers tax-advantaged real estate investments for those seeking to execute 1031 exchanges. One critical feature of any DST, which is almost certainly not adequately understood by DST investors, is the possibility of the DST “springing” into an LLC. What is the significance of a “Springing LLC,” and what key points do investors need to keep in mind when deciding whether or not a DST investment is suitable for them?

Understanding the DST: A Quick Overview

DSTs have gained popularity among real estate investors for their ability to provide tax benefits and diversification. Investors can exchange appreciated real estate for fractional ownership in a DST, thus deferring capital gains tax. The DST structure allows investors to access various commercial properties without the burden of active management, making it an attractive option for those looking to streamline their real estate portfolios.

The Springing LLC Provision

One crucial element to be aware of in DSTs is the Springing LLC provision. This provision, detailed in the Private Placement Memorandum (PPM) of all DSTs, stipulates that a DST may be converted into an LLC at the sponsor’s discretion. The primary objective of the Springing LLC provision is to provide flexibility when a DST faces significant stress, such as the need to renegotiate a lease, carry out capital improvements, refinance the property, or conduct a capital raise, actions which are not permitted in the DST structure according to IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-86. Converting into an LLC can provide the tools to address these issues effectively in such situations.

Activating the Springing LLC provision can be akin to an anti-fire sprinkler system in a building. It comes with certain downsides, but it is undoubtedly preferable to the entire “building” – in this case, the investment – going up in flames.

The Risks and Benefits of Springing LLC Activation

Once a DST springs into an LLC, critical implications must be considered. The most substantial advantage is the increased flexibility for addressing challenges and optimizing the investment’s performance.

The most significant risk is that the IRS may invalidate any follow-on 1031 exchange of the investors. Another risk is that being tied to the springing LLC will severely limit investor options.

There are two possible scenarios to consider. In the first scenario, completed in a handful of DSTs, the DST first springs into an LLC. Then, under the LLC structure, action is taken to recover and stabilize the property. Then, the LLC converts back into a DST structure. And finally, the DST is sold, and investors carry out their follow-on 1031 exchange. The risk here is that this particular scenario has yet to be ruled on by the IRS, leaving a cloud of uncertainty. There remains the potential for an IRS challenge, which would jeopardize the tax benefits investors had achieved through their 1031 exchanges to date and require them to pay the deferred capital gains based on their adjusted basis.

In the second scenario, the DST springs into an LLC but does not convert back into a DST. In this case, the LLC conducts its own 1031 exchange upon the property’s sale. This, however, requires all LLC members to participate in the same 1031 exchange into a single replacement property or choose to cash out and pay the tax. This second scenario, though more secure from an IRS challenge because there is no issue in principle with an LLC conducting a 1031 exchange, constraints the investors’ choices going forward. They would likely be constrained to remain in the same LLC long-term. On the positive side, this action probably saved their original DST investment, and if under the oversight of a good sponsor, remaining in such an LLC is far from the worst possible outcome.

In summary, while the Springing LLC provision offers an escape route during challenging times, it introduces uncertainties regarding the continuity of tax benefits and investor choice, which are crucial aspects of DST investments. It is preferable for investors if this provision is never activated. Still, the spring into an LLC can never be predicted at the time of investment and is not controlled by the investor. Therefore, DST investors need to understand this provision, how it would look if activated, and how it could positively and negatively affect their investment.

Trawnegan Gall: A Trusted Advisor

Having a knowledgeable advisor can make all the difference in this intricate landscape of DSTs and Springing LLC provisions. Trawnegan Gall, a licensed General Securities Representative at Cornerstone, has been assisting investors in navigating the complexities of tax-advantaged securitized real estate investments for a decade.

Specializing in DSTs as like-kind properties for 1031 exchanges, Trawnegan Gall has facilitated over $350 million in equity investments across more than 750 individual transactions. His wealth of experience and expertise ensures that investors are guided through the intricacies of DST investments with care and professionalism.

To learn more about Cornerstone’s services, feel free to contact Mr. Gall. His email address is trawnegan@cornerstoneexchange.com, and his phone number is (714) 939-1039. He is ready to assist you with any inquiries and provide your guidance.

Connecting with Trawnegan Gall: